Wagner's Letters

Richard Wagner to Ferdinand Heine

March 18, 1841 · Paris

Overview

Wagner tells Ferdinand Heine that reports from Laube and Devrient confirm Catholic objections to the text of Rienzi, prompting him to send Winkler proposed alterations. He argues that the Pope is treated as a temporal ruler rather than a doctrinal authority, offers possible substitutions if church language must be removed, and complains that Dresden officials will not communicate with him directly.

Letter

Quite recently my friend Laube brought to my notice remarks of Mme. Devrient which show me more clearly than ever that the ultra-Catholic party are scandalised by the text of my Rienzi. I have therefore at once informed Herr Hofrat Winkler of certain alterations on this point which I had long prepared. I have pointed out that the Pope in my libretto is not presented as a spiritual power upholding dogma, but as a temporal prince defending his earthly realm, and that his participation is slurred over as much as possible.

If they are determined to eliminate the word Church from my Rienzi altogether, I suppose one must turn to the German Emperor and ask him to shoulder the burden and pronounce the ban himself as an Imperial decree. Surely priests and religious processions have gone over the Dresden stage before now?

But what is the use of all this when these gentlemen will not favour me with one single direct communication! If they challenge me to it I shall certainly be able to remove every cause of offence. I have also been induced to write Herr Hofrat Winkler a series of letters for his Abendzeitung.

Richard Wagner

Source: Letters of Richard Wagner, Volume 1, ed. Altmann/Hull (London: Dent, 1927), No. 54