Wagner's Letters

Richard Wagner to Breitkopf and Härtel

July 27, 1843 · Teplitz

Overview

Wagner tells Breitkopf and Härtel that he is surprised they deem The Flying Dutchman worth publishing but not worth their customary opera honorarium. He reads this as proof that German publishers still value even dubious French works above original German opera, and declares he will withhold the score until theatrical success raises its value enough to command substantial payment.

Letter

Your favour of the 25th inst. gives me to understand that while you think my opera The Flying Dutchman worth the considerable cost of publication (a fact of which I am myself well assured), you do not think it worth the honorarium which you customarily pay for operas. This surprises me greatly, for I cannot understand how one could be willing to expend considerable capital upon an article which one doubted to be worth its purchase money; yet it goes to confirm a long and sadly cherished conviction of mine that an original German opera, launched under auspices however favourable, is not such sound business for a German publisher as any French work, even one with so ambiguous a history as Halévy's Charles VI. Now that I see my worst fears confirmed by the proprietors of the most respected and richest firm of music dealers in Germany, I take it as an indication that I shall do better for the present not to offer my opera elsewhere but to hold it back, and herewith take the liberty of informing you that I shall take no further steps to get my work published till its increasing success at the theatres has raised your estimate of its publication value. Be that as it may, I am determined not to place this opera in the hands of any publisher except for a substantial honorarium, since I greatly dislike the idea of condemning a publisher to the grave convinced that he has obtained a sound bargain, a conviction that he can evince only by paying the author as handsomely as his resources permit.

Richard Wagner

Source: Letters of Richard Wagner, Volume 1, ed. Altmann/Hull (London: Dent, 1927), No. 97